Lottery and stride scheduling: flexible proportional-share resource management

This thesis presents flexible abstractions for specifying resource management policies, together with efficient mechanisms for implementing those abstractions. Several novel scheduling techniques are introduced, including both randomized and deterministic algorithms that provide proportional-share control over resource consumption rates. Such control is beyond the capabilities of conventional schedulers, and is desirable across a broad spectrum of systems that service clients of varying importance. Proportional-share scheduling is examined for several diverse resources, including processor time, memory, access to locks, and disk bandwidth. Resource rights are encapsulated by abstract, first-class objects called tickets. An active client consumes resources at a rate proportional to the number of tickets that it holds. Tickets can be issued in different amounts and may be transferred between clients. A modular currency abstraction is also introduced to flexibly name, share, and protect sets of tickets. Currencies can be used to isolate or group sets of clients, enabling the modular composition of arbitrary resource management policies. Two different underlying mechanisms are introduced to support these abstractions. Lottery scheduling is a novel randomized resource allocation mechanism. An allocation is performed by holding a lottery, and the resource is granted to the client with the winning ticket. Stride scheduling is a deterministic resource allocation mechanism that computes a representation of the time interval, or stride, that each client must wait between successive allocations. Stride scheduling cross-applies and generalizes elements of rate-based flow control algorithms designed for networks to dynamically schedule other resources such as processor time. A novel hierarchical stride algorithm is also introduced that achieves better throughput accuracy than prior schemes, and can reduce response-time variability for some workloads. The proposed techniques are compared and evaluated using a variety of quantitative experiments. Simulation results and prototype implementations for operating system kernels demonstrate flexible control over a wide range of resources and applications. Thesis Supervisor: William E. Weihl Title: Associate Professor